Confessions of a Counterculture

Author's note: What follows is a (perhaps) pessimistic rumination on 2012. It is the first of two essays, the second intending toward optimism.
There are these rumors -- perhaps you have heard them -- rumors of ancient Mayan calendars and galactic cycles, lots of loose talk about sunspots and geomagnetisms, wide-eyed whispers about aliens and dimethyltryptamine, knowing nods concerning crop circles and conspiracies. An emergent and presumptive science of rapture heralds an onrushing apocalypse, and shadows cast backward through time are already stretching toward our sunset.
A feathered and snakeskin gauntlet has been thrown down, it seems, by a counterculture of psychedelic cognoscenti. Don't tell Jesus, in other words, but Quetzalcoatl is coming. An omega point looms in 2012, a transcendental object at the end of time that echoes throughout the labyrinth of human history as it draws us inexorably toward itself, or as the Tennyson inscription declares above the History statue in the Main Reading Room of the Library of Congress:
One God, one law, one element,
And one far-off divine event
To which the whole Creation moves.
When I first visited the Library of Congress in the 1990s, the late standup philosopher Terence McKenna, in his irresistible nasal charisma, was proclaiming this same poetry, albeit in a science fiction vocabulary. Angels or aliens, destiny or timewave zero, revelation or exponential novelty, it was a fresh rehash of the apocalyptic romanticism that has enriched Western Civilization for centuries (and a romanticism that I readily confess has possessed my own writing). Only now, for reasons that remain to be revealed, a sort of now-or-never ultimatum has been wagered, a line has been drawn in the sand spilling out of the broken hourglass of history, as if we're daring the devil to drop his gawdamn pitchfork or else... or else... or else...
Of course, we have no else with which to fulfill this threat, but we wager nonetheless on the en masse enlightenment of humanity. It's a long shot, doubtless the superlative of its category, for a global spiritual awakening includes not only organic North Bay yogis but also corporate criminals lounging in their seeping pits of avarice, and hey, let's not forget the truck driver jerking off over a crumpled Hustler in a gas station bathroom outside of Vegas. The depravity of the human condition can hardly be realized, so if nothing else, the en masse enlightenment of humanity is a bold bet, and maybe a bold bet is the only way to hit the jackpot. But if I'm not entirely convinced that it's ludicrous, it's only because I also suspect that the game of life is fixed and the house always wins, and anyway, such contemplation never fails to leave me in a sparkling good mood, like a Beach Boys song.
But let's really examine this. Between the yammer of a legion of gurusional prophets and the hammer of Hollywood's own hijack of this bandwagon, there persists an earnest belief that this really is it, that Albert Hofmann's 1943 bicycle ride was no coincidence, that acid was the antidote to nuclear weapons, that Jesus was a mushroom, that the Beatles were the four horsemen of the apocalypse, and that Ken Kesey's electric kool-aid Grateful Dead flower child Burning Man mass mysticism is a teaser trailer for the next epoch of human evolution.
Admittedly, there is something enthralling about this narrative. Redemption, after all, is a theme that religious institutions have regaled us with tales of for millennia. There is an undeniable longing for this, protecting as it does the naked underbelly of the human psyche, that pink vulnerability that tries not to notice that we actually haven't a clue what the antichrist is happening. But the sense that something is missing, and the hope that this will somehow shift -- these are universal yearnings of the human condition, no matter the century.
So who knows? Human history does seem determined in its violent banality, and maybe it will require the messianic intervention of the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy to liberate us from our own terrifyingly obsolete social structures. Maybe Hunter S. Thompson was mistaken when he wrote about the "old-mystic fallacy" of the counterculture, "the desperate assumption that somebody -- or at least some force -- is tending the light at the end of the tunnel." But at the risk of branding myself a braying heretic, I must confess that my credulity perished when I witnessed a jubilant throng of terrifically attractive 21st-century humans really truly honest dancing chantingly believe that a particularly striking lenticular cloud capturing the sunsetting desert sky above Burning Man was an alien mothership there to cast blessings upon our bacchanalia.
Unquestionably, it was a beautiful cloud, and that was reason enough for my own jubilation, like the moonbow that haloed the sky two nights before, or the double rainbow that graced the playa two years prior. Our blessed Earth is capable of beauty that exceeds belief, but I don't think it ill-mannered to mention that the emperor has no clothes here, and that cloud was no flying saucer. With this in mind, perhaps you will pardon my pessimism as I wonder aloud if the latter-day counterculture has been hoodwinked by a slew of Luciferian diversions presuming to promise salvation.
As much as my mind reels at the notion that our sun is a dimensional protrusion concentrated from a crackling canvas of cosmic background radiation, as fascinating as it is to consider that our neurochemistry could be influenced by meta-astrological phenomena, as thrilling as it is to contemplate that as our sun moves into some kind of geomagnetic alignment with the black hole at the center of our galaxy that our pineal glands will dump their DMT and a transcendental sunrise will sweep across the Earth as each among us gasps into a galactivation of consciousness and we awaken at last to unity undivided understood and forever fathomed -- for that matter, as much as I would love to write another novel with such a bumping plot -- I have to confess, I'm looking around, and I'm not really getting that impression.
What I'm getting instead is the sense that we've hyped ourselves for a letdown, that what passes for the latter-day counterculture has traded its prankster roots for something resembling, umm, a culture, a culture complete with ritual, status, fashion, and prophecy. The definition of counterculture accepted into the official lexicon generally has something to do with an oppositional culture rejecting the dominant culture. Etymologically, however (and historically, for progenitors of the term are known to have said as much), counterculture means exactly what it states -- the opposite of culture, all culture. Despite McKenna's ominous admonition that "culture is not your friend," it's unlikely that culture is necessarily your foe. It's just that, fundamentally, culture is an illusion of security, predictability, identity, and order, and is therefore inherently false. Culture is useful, of course, and a constant human compulsion, but culture is an inevitable narrowing into a fixed perspective. Counterculture, then, is the opposite of any such reduction of reality -- Mayan or otherwise -- from anything other than unbounded creative potential. Counterculture, in other words, is the reveling chaos of relentless novelty that exists outside our social constructions, and as soon as we pretend to know what's happening, it ceases to be counterculture and immediately becomes culture.
Granting for a moment a dark and hyperbolic parallel, consider that in concentration camps, rumors only as improbable as an Allied liberation occasionally overtook the imprisoned. Reflecting on his own Auschwitz experiences in Man's Search for Meaning, Victor Frankl observed that such rumors typically resulted in elation as the starving anticipated their salvation. When liberation did not come to pass, however, Frankl also noted a horrifying die-off as hopelessness set in. Thankfully, the overall human condition is not yet comparable to that of a concentration camp. But there is an undeniable plague of spiritual starvation upon us, and I can't help but feel some dismay when I see grandiose hopes for salvation placed at a point in the alleged future that I have no compelling reason to believe will feel any different than right this very instant right now.
The truth is stranger than fiction, Lord Byron poeticized, and as I have witnessed my own satirical endeavors outpaced by the absurdities of our commerce-begotten world, I have sometimes been tempted to exchange my storytelling for the wild fascinations of history. But then I remember that there's really no difference, that story, history, prophecy, and the human experience itself are all made of the same carried away garble of grunts. And anyway, if the truth is stranger than fiction, then as strange as this 2012 business is, if we can contain it in words it is still only fiction, and I think that's okay, because I think in the end the truth will be stranger still.
If you were the dreamer of all dreams conceiving the climax of human redemption, could you really satisfy yourself with a cheap deus ex machina twist, an all-at-once fell swoop shazamaranza? That is a simple fiction, and the stranger truth is that God is the sum of all histories, that there are countless billions of fractal fictions all facing our own apocalypse and seeking our own salvation. The stranger truth is that each and all of us will suffer uncontainable loss: broken hearts, shattered dreams, disease, misfortune, attachment, addiction, death. The stranger truth is that children lose their limbs to bombs, parents lose their children to ideology, lovers lose their love to resentment, soldiers lose their sanity to duty, and generations lose their hope to propaganda. The stranger truth is that our bodies will fail, our social systems will collapse, and the strangest truth of all is that there we will be, each of us alone, the protagonist of our own private fiction, until someday come doomsday, one by one across billions of lives, we give up, and we wake up, and we remember that the only thing we've ever really wanted to do is love, and as I pause at the close of this evening's contemplation, it occurs to me that all of these concepts and ideas are impostors, pretending to have something to say,
other than yes.
Image by listentoreason, courtesy of Creative Commons license.
Tweet- 4-21-10
- Tony V's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version










Comments
Cosmic Soup
Where ever humans gather together they "culture" ... just like the ingredients in yogurt ... as we mix together "new" ideas and experience generate.
There is no possibility of existing "counter" to such cultivation/culture. {so much for the play on words/ideas
Endless possibilities ... all of us have ideas and feelings ... hence culture everywhere.
If we leave our most genuine ideas and feelings aside the culture is weak ...
It is natural and unavoidable.
We just have to learn to only put "good" things into the mix and we will surprise ourselves with the outcome
NOW!
Counter culture
Change is coming
Beautifully written, and a fair assessment of the current situation; to an extent. The bottom line is that we create change and revolution, and while there is startling evidence for those still locked in what I'll call "forgetfulness" there is the same evidence for those that I'll call "awakened." You'll find it in Quantum Physics, renewed interest in the spiritual traditions of the East such as Reiki, transcendental meditation, holistic medicine, energy healing, etc. You'll also find it in organizations such as Humanity’s Team petitioning the United Nations for a world oneness day, and Integral Enlightment who recently did a free teleseminar series called the great Integral Awakening that got tens of thousands of listeners, and so many others. We can see the desire for change and a renewed interest in making it a reality with our reaction to the current issues facing us, such as 37 states preparing to sue the federal government over the recent health care passage, public outrage over the recent Supreme Court decision removing the limit on Corporate political funding, and a recent Rasmussen poll that shows Congressman Ron Paul in a dead tie with President Obama should the 2012 election be held today, and he has ideas that could be called very "radical".
So, moral of the story is change is coming without question. It may or may not happen in 2012 because of some cosmic global reset, but we shouldn't be waiting for that anyway. That's not the point of this whole global spiritual awakening, the point is to wake up and take action now. To stop waiting for some savior on high, or benevolent light being from the Pleiades to come save us, because we are the ones we have been waiting for. Will we do it in 2012? Probably not, but I think that's when we it gets started, the end of the world as we know it. What we recreate over this mess, is entirely up to us. Time to decide what the new world is going to look like :D
"We are not human beings having a spiritual experience. We are spiritual beings
having a human experience."
- Pierre Teilhard de Chardi
DCS
http://www.themindofdcs.com
Very well written...
seems like an attachment issue to me
Nailed it.
An End To Romanticism?
This article is very astute, I think. If there is a cultural shift going on of any meaningful size, it will, among other things, have to take us past Romanticism. I mean Romanticism in the tired and degenerate form in which it manifests in the early twenty-first century. Such as:
* The culture of the "artiste maudit"--the poor, suffering artist who must needs rebel against society, chiefly by self-destructive methods (Baudelaire mutated into Courtney Love);
* The eighteenth-century notion that "culture is not your friend," that all we need to do is strip away the evil veneer that civilization has imposed upon us and we will be beautiful, loving little sun children.
* The conceit that all "civilized" people are bad and all "native" people are good.
* The idea that art is of necessity what Nietzsche called "Dionysian"--wild, chaotic, formless, and (preferably) devoid of content;
* The belief that the rational, conceptual mind is the root of all wickedness.
These concepts and ideals are not good or bad in and of themselves; no doubt in 1770 they were stimulating and healthful. But this is not 1770.
2012 Tipping Point
Anyone who wakes up on 12/22/2012 should not be disappointed, but rather that person should be joyful! No one wants to go through an apocalypse. (I should know, I have been through a few.)
I think we are approaching, as McKenna said, an end of history -- what went before will not be very helpful. The internet has made many forms of knowledge obsolete. What is going to be needed are people who can do things, empathetic things, efficient things (including accounting for externalities), and honesty/truth are going to be a major part of any sustainable strategy. This is why I believe we are rapidly approaching the tipping point. Scientists say that we can't reverse the trend of global warming. But Mother Nature can.
The question is how does one genetically invest in climate reorganization? What information have we learned over the past 200 years, 6,000 years, or 600,000 years that will help us either individually or collectively cope with such a "judgment day"? You either live or die, and there will be no appeals to the Supreme Court of the United States. (Justice would probably be carried out slowly and would be considered swift only by geologic stadards.)
The only answers I can find on how to reasonably deal with a non-interventionist apocalypse comes from people like Jesus, Ghandi, Martin Luther King Jr., Terrence McKenna, Stalking Wolf, Guru Nanak and others who not only taught, but lived true to their words. And they all stressed loving your self, your neighbor, and your enemy. (I believe Moses and Muhammad taught and lived these things too, although I am not familiar enough with their lives to be certain.)
I think we should double down on the world ending on 12/21/2012 -- as long as that world is centered on Wall Street, Pennsylvania Avenue, etc. Rather my world should be centered where I am at that point, yours should be where you are, and so on. Anything besides benevolent self-centered awareness will be extremely painful going forward.
Counter-culture stereotypes
You write, "What I'm getting instead is the sense that we've hyped ourselves for a letdown, that what passes for the latter-day counterculture has traded its prankster roots for something resembling, umm, a culture, a culture complete with ritual, status, fashion, and prophecy."
I have definitely noticed this, and this is probably the single thing about Burning Man and the counter-culture in general that I do not like. It seems to me that all that a lot of people are doing is setting themselves up to become another stereotype--albeit an attractive and radical one, but a stereotype nonetheless.
If I go to Burning Man and I don't want to wear peacock feathers and neo-tribal leather accessories with sacred geometry symbols, what does this make me? Am I not "cool"? Am I not "counter-culture"? I definitely got that vibe from some people while I was an outsider experiencing Burning Man for the first time, and it bothered me. I had thought that the whole point was to abandon routines, abandon stereotypes, and achieve some kind of real, non-rhetorical egalitarian "freedom".
I feel that Burning Man is almost there, but the same old social hierarchies, assumptions, power struggles, and desire to be outwardly admired for physical beauty and superficial traits are still present. I would encourage us all to be ourselves rather than trying to create some new kind of counter-culture hipster persona. If we can realize this and be comfortable with who we are instead of latching on to images and hierarchies, we will be free.
Freedom for some in Cluelessness
Tony, I love the honesty and perhaps the bravery involved with submitting such a piece, especially in the forum that RS seems to champion: 2012 Awakening. A credit to you and to RS for daring to look at the other side.
Your article questions the potential for hype and/or delusion in our quest for knowing what, if anything 2012 will offer. And in other points you seem to question 'knowing' itself, and to this I would like to share a perspective that hopefully, will not disrupt this wonderful thread. I apologize just in case, as I am relatively new to 'computer-writing.'
Personally, I don't have a problem with how anyone needs to move into greater awareness; I figure it all works out. As my moniker infers, I am (finally) clueless after many years on the path. And from this genuine perspective and as I suspect you understand, it is difficult to write about anything these days, for all it seems to do is to bring me out of inner-experience and challenge the comfort and growth in my unknowing. And yet, here I am... literally feeling my way in this 'conversation' because I need to occasionally look out of the Silence to 'chat.'
You offer the following quotes (with my emphasis): "Culture is useful, of course, and a constant human compulsion, but culture is an inevitable narrowing into a fixed perspective. Counterculture, then, is the opposite of any such reduction of reality."---- "and as soon as we pretend to know what's happening, it ceases to be counterculture and immediately becomes culture."
These statements are very insightful in that they perhaps illuminate the door for the freedom of the Unknown to be seriously contemplated. Is it okay or even wise to be so ignorant (of this 3-D world)? Does this description conjure up an image of a drooling, lazy, go-with-the-flow, imbecile? Or of someone who is 'contrary' to those who work with intention and other self-determinist means? Hardly the truth of my experiences- though common misunderstandings for the uninitiated.
Not having a clue is to live in the present moment with Source -always. This is a sacred space of breath/feeling/mind consciousness that teaches and grows acute awareness to all that is occurring in the world; the visible and the invisible... For those who are drawn to this journey of 'doing nothing,' we are deep in the trenches touching existence that can't be seen beyond myth, breath and imagination. We assist people's energy-fields through the Silence of Acceptance and move on; It's often 'tuff' work. As the poet Roberto Duran offers: "Just because I'm standing still, doesn't mean I'm not moving." And Rumi offers: "Intellectuals plan their repose; lovers are ashamed to rest."
Tony, your ending comment is deliciously curious: "it occurs to me that all of these concepts and ideas are impostors, pretending to have something to say." Yes, indeed, there are other (hidden) realms of deep spiritual service that are rarely if ever defended because the opening of our mouths risks losing the pearl of inner experience (Rumi). We honor the ways of everyone, for 2012 will bring what 2012 will bring.
"The greatest Love is Love with no object. For then, you yourself, have become Love itself." -Rumi
2012 mania
2012 mania
Great Read Twist! Thanks, really brought home for me that perhaps what is currently happening is more than enough to warrant or justify the so called end/beginning of a cycle. The utterly transmutational period of the 20th century alone was as creative as it was destructive. There are infinite cycles in existence, maybe one is not more important or weighted than the other, every cyclic breath we take is an epic transformation of the structure of our being, yet we dont seem to give much credence or dare I say potential to that. Perhaps one cycle of our breath is just as integral to the 'multiverse' as anything else.
No need for romantic religious "Mt Sinai" styled instant coffee psychadelic enlightenment events. Life is surreal and amazing enough as it is perhaps. But our historically repeated longings always want more, we "crave" connection with our source, in turn increasing our distance from it and escalating the experience of suffering, as opposed to dissolving it. To paraphrase Seinfeld: "Not that there's anything wrong with that!!"
Padmasambhava was right, enlightenment is being sold on every street corner now, including this very wonderful website. It has its pros and cons of course, like anything. All a reflection of where we are at personally and collectively I guess.
WARNING: Abstract / Existential Conjectured Rant:
For me its not so much about WHAT you're doing (ayahuascua, meditation, whatever) IT's more WHERE-abouts in the vast archetypal / traumatised projected geography of the human condition we are doing "IT" from. You can have 10 people drinking ayahuasca in a circle, but they're all drinking it and singing icaros from different locations in the human condition, some more egocentric, some more romantic, some archetypal, some traumatic, and it's that unique conditioning which will dictate the experience that you have (or more accurately - project) - an intricate system of stories that we all carry, an energetic anatomy, some personal, some shared, which are endlessly reinforced and transmuted by our reactions to them. Experience is phenomenological, phenomena is infinite and endless - perhaps the choice is about: Do we get lost (and reactive) in infinite phenomena (human projections)? OR do we somehow "give" those experiences to our whole self, realising that they are really a miniscule fraction of our true or real self, a self that always was and always will be "there". Perhaps you can orientate the human condition back to its source, perhaps energetically it is at our centre of gravity, our core. Not the projected experience of core, our real one - I DONT KNOW :) Some energetic teachers I have learnt from seem to believe so.
:)
Lash's Take on 2012
Mystical confidence
Wow Twist, you had me at "A multi-frequency surge of mystical confidence is spreading through some areas of the youth culture."
=)
I think you're right. Perhaps this has something to do with the internet and social networking and the new kind of informational nexus we are embedded in now. Also I think people have become less gullible and have less faith in the old dying institutions of authority, and have learned to instead place faith in themselves and their own desires.
Instead of growing up under the oppressive thumb of monolithic Christianity, many of us in the younger generations have been allowed to experience all kinds of spiritual truths and different paths to explore. I think the New Age and multi-culturalism in general has been helpful for this. The 2012 meme is a good example.
Whether or not 2012 has any value remains to be seen, but I know there is value in re-imagining our society. We are probably at the end of an era and close to the beginning of a new one, insofar as our relationships with religion, communication, information, society and ourselves. It's like the future is a wave about to crest and we can almost see it, so everyone is excited....
I believe one of the best
Astral Circus Distraction?
BraVO!!
I enjoyed the article so much because it dare to look at 2012 date, from a transparent and sober perspective. I have to say that placing hopes in a deus ex machine event is placing our power away from our hands.... Yes truth is stranger than fiction but in the sense that we are the makers of the future, the people will either make the shift into a new paradigm through our own will not a cosmic ray or an Alien race. We do have the power to change and we do have the power to fail and degenerate till the planet can't take us anymore. While some people might see this article as a let down, I see it as clear look into ourselves and to our responsabilities as being that inhabit this planet.
Bravo!!!
The Big Shift
This essay struck a chord with me since I've had the same kind of thoughts as Tony V articulates.
My hopeful self dreams that some mystical shift in human consciousness will happen all at once, perhaps as Mother Earth itself goes through an unseen warp in space/time itself, to propel us into a different timeline and a more positive path than the one to which we seem so inexorably headed...that of utter destruction.
Or perhaps something so simple as the mythical "Hundreth Monkey" theory, the one last human being needed to make the choice of raising their awareness to accept the Oneness of All Life, enabling a wave of raised consciousness to spread through the rest of humanity. Sort of a positive opposite of what happened with the wave of terror and fear consciousness that engulfed the planet on 9-11, so why not something wonderful???
Then my more 'rational and realistic' self is calling Dec. 21, 2012, the "Big Nothing". I also think of the Dick Cheneys of the world along with all the other slime balls, sociopaths, psychopaths, warmongers and other sundry types of brigands and miscreants there are, and can't even imagine them jumping on board Cat Stevens' "Peace Train" of Universal Love and Brotherhood.
Just as others here have said before me, I really DON'T KNOW. I just keep hoping against all hope for the best outcome with the least amount of pain and misery; hasn't humanity had enough of that in it's lamentable and piteous history?
It won't be what you imagine.....
I don't believe anything
I don't believe anything will happen in 2012, at least nothing supernatural anyway.
I think it will be business as usual. There will be the same old miserable news articles, the same old environmental and human exploitation, the same old naive ignorant belief systems, the same old corrupt and greedy governments and corporations, the same old chaotic mess.
The world will slowly but surely worsen, overpopulated, polluted and degraded, and very little to nothing positive will be done to turn it around.I'll get older and my hopes for a bright future will fade ever further.
I hope I'm wrong, but gauging past experience as an indicator for future behaviour, then what I perceive above, is what the evidence suggests.
Get a load of Captain Bringdown...
Remind me to book you as an inspirational speaker if we're ever mass interned in prison camps.
This is of course intelligent and well-written, which I always appreciate, as do I your critical faculties Tony. Lord knows this counterculture you describe could sure benefit from a healthy dose of critical thinking. And I am once again amused by your love of hyperbole (you really can make one thread the entire carpet). But don't you think you're kinda biting the hand that feeds you here (lest we remind the reader you write about "synchronicity" as if it were a science)? It seems like you barely tried to mask your contempt.
More to the point, even though, yes, there are historical patterns to various apocalyptic, Millenarian, and transformative-transcendentalist visions, there is nothing ordinary about the times we are living in. We stand at the convergence of multiple interconnected systemic crises, and that alone is enough to reshuffle the whole deck on humanity. I think people have yet to realize that *some* people will make it through the transition, but not *most.* Still, don't piss on people for holding on to hope, it's what makes us human.
What would you have them do, become cynical college professors? Condo-owning yuppies? Marketing directors? At least they believe in something: they believe in the human potential. So long as we're still doing that, we're moving towards the possibility of a solution, however slow or misguided.
Yes, there are a lot of empty new age palliatives circulating, and this looming 2012 date--already burned into the collective consciousness--does not help. But these are natural reactions to a culture of fear, and an outward expression of spiritual seeking in an era of anomie. People have a right to be afraid, even if their fear manifests itself as a kind of vapid, puerile denial and pseudoscience. What we should do is instead of mocking them, or giving up on them, is help educate them properly, and teach them how to channel their fear into action.
But it's kinda hard to do that while looking down your nose at them.
Charles Shaw
Author - Exile Nation
Author's Note
Permit me to reiterate the Author's Note at the beginning of this essay:
[This was] a (perhaps) pessimistic rumination on 2012. It is the first of two essays, the second intending toward optimism.
In any event, I am grateful for the discussion this essay has stimulated. Although I have certainly desired to, I haven't had sufficient time to participate more fully.
Stay tuned for Part 2...
Tony V
www.tonyvigorito.com